Strings and Interpolation: A Love Story (Part 1)

Posted: September 29, 2011 in PHP, PHP, Tutorial, Uncategorized, Web Development
Tags: , , , , , ,

I am a frequent forum goer to the website http://www.phpfreaks.com/ (My username is Mikesta707), and one thing I see a lot from PHP novices is a question like

Hey, I am trying to echo a string, but it doesn’t look right. I’m using a variable and but instead of its value all I see is the php code! my code looks like

$str = "Poop";

echo 'I have to take a $str';

please halp!

Now, anyone who has uses PHP at an intermediate level or higher will tell this hypothetical novice to either use double quotes, or concatenate. The solutions would be as follows


$str = "Poop";

echo "I have to take a $str";//double quotes

echo 'I have to take a ' . $str;//concatenation

And of course, their error will be fixed, and they can go on their merry way, or post about another problem they have. In addition to the above solutions, one could also use heredoc syntax, but that is generally reserved for multi-line strings and can be a little complex for a new programmer. Many forum posters wouldn’t bother even mentioning it.

Anyways, what many posters fail to do in these cases, is explain why what they wrote failed. As a result of this, even people who know to use double quotes or concatenate will often not really know why you have to do that, beyond “uh.. just because man.”  In my experience as a forum poster for phpfreaks, I see a solution that concatenates rather than using double quotes more frequently, and this produces a very interesting effect.

Concatenation is simple enough, and easy to rationalize the use of without wondering why you were wrong. Without knowing about the use of double quotes (or simply not realizing), one may naturally assume, after having the above problem and being told to concatenate, that they can’t put variables inside strings.

This is half correct, as it is true with single quotes, but incorrect in terms of double quotes. This can lead an overall assumption that if you want to create a string that is composed partly of one or more variables, then you must always concatenate. Over the years I have worked with quite a few developers who have been looking over my shoulder while I am writing some code, and told me, “Hey, you gotta concatenate there!” or something along those lines when using double quotes. Usually this will come with the look of quiet satisfaction at having corrected (or thinking they corrected) a fellow coder’s mistake.

Unfortunately, because of this assumption many people miss out on one of my favorite features of PHP called Interpolation,  as well as having a somewhat faulty understanding of how strings work in PHP. For those who don’t know, interpolation is defined by Wikipedia as the following:

The process of evaluating an expression or string literal containing one or more variables, yielding a result in which the variables are replaced with their corresponding values in memory. It is a specialized instance of concatenation.

Now this basically means that when you put a variable inside of a string, PHP does a sort of replace, where the name of the variable (say, $str) is replaced with its value (say, “Poop”). PHP supports interpolation, but only when using double quotes or the heredoc string syntax. To take a simple example:

//The following are all equivalent
$n = "Mike";
echo "Hi i'm $n";//interpolation
echo 'Hi i\'m ' . $n;//concatenation
echo <<<EOT
Hi i'm $n
EOT;//heredoc syntax

As I said earlier, Interpolation is one of my favorite attributes of PHP. Interpolation isn’t supported in many languages (Perl, Tcl, Ruby and most unix shells are the others). PHP uses a sigil, or a symbol attached to a variable to show its a variable (and not a global constant), unlike many languages (including C, C++, C#, java, javascript, etc.) so interpolation is possible. Interpolation really makes creating strings that would be complex or look ugly in other languages easy and clean. Lets compare two strings, one in PHP and one in C++/C#/Java/ect…


//assume we have created 3 variables, $a $b and $c in PHP, and a b and c in C++

//PHP string
$str = "The first 3 letters of the alphabet are $a $b and $c";

//equivalent string in C++/C#/java/etc...
//assume we have the proper header includes
string str = "The first 3 letters of the alphabet are " + a + " " + b + " and " + c;

As you can see, the PHP version is much easier on the eyes, and much nicer to write! Of course, most languages that don’t support interpolation have a specialized form of interpolation in function form using string formatting (for example, printf() from C/Lisp).

To sum things up, I absolutely love interpolation, and think its one of the most amazing features of PHP. Its a very simple feature, but elegant at the same time, and extremely useful. Out of all of PHP’s amazing features, I know that I use this one the most. I love interpolation so much actually, that I plan on writing a part 2 to this post very soon. It will probably be a tad bit shorter, but will have some good information.

Part 2: [Click me]

Links of Interest:

String parsing (Interpolation):
http://www.php.net/manual/en/language.types.string.php#language.types.string.parsing

Single quotes:
http://www.php.net/manual/en/language.types.string.php#language.types.string.syntax.single

Double quotes:
http://www.php.net/manual/en/language.types.string.php#language.types.string.syntax.double

Heredoc:
http://www.php.net/manual/en/language.types.string.php#language.types.string.syntax.heredoc

Interpolation (Wikipedia):
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Variable_(computer_science)#Interpolation

Comments
  1. I’ve read several good stuff here. Definitely worth bookmarking for revisiting. I wonder how much effort you put to create such a great informative website.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s